Why is slate repaired rather than replaced with shingle?
Because the stone itself commonly outlasts several asphalt coverings, so a roof whose units are sound is an asset rather than a liability. Swapping it for shingle also changes the appearance of an older house, which matters to the house and, in a local historic district, to the review that applies to it.
There is a structural side as well. Slate is heavy, and the framing under an old slate roof was built for that weight. Taking it off does no harm structurally, but putting it back on a roof that has been shingled for decades is a different question, and so is adding a heavy simulated product to framing that was never sized for one.
The appearance question is formal in some places. New Haven's Historic District Commission reviews roofing material in local districts and has considered both like-kind replacement and simulated slate. If the house is in such a district, check with the commission before deciding, as the historic district roof work page describes.
How can you tell nail failure from stone failure?
Look at the pattern and at the pieces that come down. Stone that is failing flakes, delaminates and sounds dead when tapped. Nails that are failing leave sound pieces slipping out of line in scattered positions across the plane, often with a short length of corroded shank still in the wood.
The distinction decides the whole strategy. Sound stone on dead nails can be taken down, sorted and rehung on new fasteners, which keeps the roof that belongs on the house. Dead stone on good nails cannot be rescued by any amount of hand repair, because every piece replaced puts stress on brittle neighbors.
Mixed conditions are the common reality on a roof that is a century old. A roofer who has been on the plane can usually give you a rough proportion of sound pieces, which is the single most useful number in the conversation about what to do next.
- Slipped but intact pieces scattered over the plane point to fasteners
- Flaking faces, soft edges and a dull sound when tapped point to the stone
- Damage grouped in one area points to impact or to foot traffic
- Staining concentrated under a valley or a chimney points to metal, not to either
What harm does walking on a slate roof do?
A great deal. Stone is strong across its face and brittle at the edges and the fastener holes, so weight in the wrong place cracks pieces that were sound. Damage from a single careless visit is often discovered months later as a leak with no storm to explain it.
Crews that work on slate move on ladders, hooks, staging and roof boards that spread load away from the exposed stone, and they plan a route before they step. This is also why a roof of this kind should not be climbed by a homeowner, an antenna installer, a chimney sweep or anyone else without the right equipment and the habit of working on stone.
The hidden cost of foot traffic is a reason to get a written condition record when the roof is next inspected. The roof inspection report page covers what such a record contains and why buyers of older houses here ask for one.
What happens in winter on a slate roof?
Slate sheds snow in sheets once the sun gets at it, and it suffers the same eave icing as any other covering when attic heat melts snow that refreezes at a cold edge. The brittleness of the stone is what changes the response: ice should not be chipped off a slate roof.
Ice that forms behind a dam can back water up over the head lap of the lowest courses, and on an old roof there may be no membrane beneath to stop it. The result is staining at the top of an upstairs wall with no broken stone anywhere in sight.
The right fix is to deal with the heat and the air that cause the melting, and to clear ice with steam rather than tools. That work is described on the ice dam removal and repair page, and snow guards are sometimes added on a slate roof to stop whole sheets releasing over a doorway.