Why is hail damage so often disputed?
Because it is small, it looks like wear to an untrained eye, and the same roof may carry both. A report based on photographs taken from a distance can read either way, and that is where arguments come from. Careful, dated, close-up evidence by slope is what settles them.
A television report in the Torrington area of Litchfield County described hail claims as hard to prove, which matches the experience of anybody who has stood on a roof trying to decide whether a mark is three weeks old or three years old. Nothing about that is unique to one insurer or one town.
The lesson for a homeowner is procedural rather than technical. Photograph the stones on the day, with something for scale. Note the time. Photograph the marks on your gutters and your garden furniture. That is the material that makes an inspection conclusive rather than arguable.
Does cosmetic damage matter?
It matters structurally only if the mat is fractured or the material is holed. Granule loss in a few spots on a sound covering is largely appearance. A notice from the Connecticut Insurance Department in March 2024 said cosmetic roof discoloration and streaking do not support non-renewal of a policy.
That distinction is worth holding onto in both directions. It is a reason not to replace a roof over a handful of marks, and a reason not to accept an argument that a visibly marked but functionally sound roof has become uninsurable because of its appearance.
Where the mat is genuinely fractured, the picture is different. Those shingles will fail sooner than their neighbors and the failure shows up as leaks over the following years rather than during the storm, which is why the finding is recorded even when nothing is leaking yet.
- Granules knocked off, mat intact: appearance and some loss of life
- Mat fractured under the impact: real damage, recorded even if dry today
- Shingle punctured or slate broken: water path now, repair now
- Metal dented but functional: evidence of the event rather than damage to fix
What else does a hail storm damage?
Usually the softer things first. Skylight domes, plastic vent housings, gutter troughs and downspouts take marks before a sound shingle field does, and window screens, siding on the storm-facing elevation and garden structures often record the event more clearly than the roof.
A roofer looks at those surfaces precisely because they are more sensitive than the covering. A roof with no marks under a skylight dome full of dents is telling you something about how much the covering actually absorbed.
Skylights deserve their own look after a hail storm, because a cracked dome will leak and a crazed one will fail later. That is the subject of the skylight replacement page.
How does this inspection differ from a general storm check?
It is more forensic and more local in its focus. A wind inspection is about edges, seals and missing material; a hail inspection is about counting impacts in measured areas on specific slopes and deciding what caused each mark. The two often happen in the same visit after a severe storm.
In this county the wind half is usually the substantive half. The National Weather Service's records for the big local events describe wind and surge rather than hail, and the one sizable hail report in the area, at Cheshire in 2007, came from a crowd-sourced source rather than an official measurement.
If a storm brought both, have both looked at in one visit and recorded separately, since they damage a roof in different ways. The general process is described on the storm damage roof inspection page.