Why is sealant not the answer?
Because a joint between two materials moves with every change of temperature, and no bead of sealant stays intact across that movement for long. Sealant across a flashing is a repair with a short clock on it, and while it holds it hides the fault from the next person who looks.
A correctly built junction works by geometry rather than adhesion. Each piece of metal is lapped so that water running down the roof passes over the top of the piece below and is carried out onto the covering. Nothing is glued shut; the water is simply never given a path inward.
There is a worse version of the sealant repair, which is tar or cement smeared across a valley or around a chimney. It traps moisture against the metal and the wood, corrodes from behind, and has to be chipped off before a proper repair can be made. Old houses here are full of these.
How does a water test actually work?
Water is applied to a small area at a time, starting at the lowest point of the suspect zone and moving upslope in stages, with somebody inside watching the stain. The moment water appears inside, the last area wetted is the source. Patience is the whole technique.
The reason for working from the bottom up is that water applied high runs over everything below it, so a leak would prove nothing about where the fault was. Each stage gets enough time for water to travel, which on a long rafter run can be several minutes.
A test is not always possible. In freezing weather, on a roof that is unsafe to be on, or where the suspected area is inside a finished ceiling with no access, the diagnosis has to rest on inspection and on the weather history instead. A roofer should tell you which of those situations you are in.
- Start below the suspect area and work upslope in small stages
- One person on the roof, one inside watching the stain, in contact throughout
- Allow minutes, not seconds, for water to travel the roof structure
- Stop as soon as water appears inside and record exactly where the hose was
Which junctions fail first on an older house?
Vent collars, chimney flashing and valleys, in roughly that order, followed by sidewall details where there is no kick-out. These fail before the field of the covering does, which is why a sound-looking roof of moderate age can still be leaking in three places.
Age plays out differently in metal and in the covering. A vent collar's flexible seal is the shortest-lived part of a roof; valley metal thins and splits slowly; a chimney detail usually fails because the mortar joint holding the counterflashing has weathered rather than because the metal has gone.
On a house that has been altered, the junctions created by the alteration are the ones to look at hardest. A dormer added in the 1950s, a rear ell with its own roof, a porch converted to a room: those details were built once and often not very well, and they are where water is likely getting in.
What does the local weather pattern do to junctions?
Nor'easters drive rain horizontally for hours, which finds any detail relying on gravity alone. Winter ice loads the eaves and works water back under the lowest courses. Summer thunderstorms deliver intense short bursts that overwhelm valleys and blocked gutters.
The horizontal rain of a long coastal storm is the hardest test a flashing gets, and it explains why many leaks here only appear in weather from one direction. A homeowner who notices that pattern has effectively done half the diagnostic work already.
Winter adds its own path, and it is the one most often mistaken for flashing failure. Water that has backed up behind ice at the eave appears at the top of a wall, exactly where a bad sidewall detail would show, so the time of year matters to the diagnosis. The mechanism is described on the ice dam removal and repair page.