Why does sealing the brickwork never last?
Because masonry, metal and wood all move at different rates with temperature, so a bead of sealant along a brick face is being stretched and compressed every day. It splits, and once it splits it channels water into the gap it was meant to close.
A properly cut counterflashing does not depend on anything sticking. The metal turns into the wall, so there is no exposed seam facing upward for water to sit in. That is a geometric solution rather than a chemical one, and it is why the method has not changed in a very long time.
The face-nailed and sealed version is quick, cheap and extremely common on older houses here. It usually gives a few years. When a homeowner reports that the chimney has been flashed twice already and still leaks, this is almost always what has been done.
What else sends water down a chimney?
The crown at the top, the absence of a cap, open mortar joints in the stack, and a flue liner that has failed. All of these take water into the chimney itself, where it emerges inside the house and looks exactly like a flashing leak.
A cracked crown is the most frequent of these. It is the slab at the top of the stack, it takes the full weather, and when it splits water runs straight into the masonry and down inside. A missing cap lets rain fall directly down the flue, which on a disused chimney has nowhere to go but into the brick.
This is why a roofer will ask about the top of the chimney before talking about the flashing. Chimney work above the roof line is often a masonry or sweeping matter rather than a roofing one, and spending money on new flashing while the crown is open is money wasted.
- Flashing failure: staining appears where the stack passes through the roof
- Crown or cap failure: damp bricks inside, often at a lower floor as well
- Open mortar joints: damp patches that follow long, wind-driven rain
- Condensation in a disused flue: staining with no rain to explain it
How does the chimney tie into winter problems?
In two ways. The stack interrupts the slope, so snow drifts and meltwater collect on its uphill side and freeze there. And the chase around a chimney inside the house is often an open air path from the basement to the attic, delivering warm air straight to the roof deck.
The first of those is a drainage problem solved with a cricket and a clear back pan. The second is an air-sealing problem, and it is one of the largest single leaks in many older houses, because the gap around a masonry chimney was traditionally left open for clearance.
Sealing that gap needs non-combustible material and careful detailing, not expanding foam, and it is usually done as part of the attic work described on the attic ventilation for ice dams page. The winter consequence of not doing it is on the ice dam removal and repair page.
When is chimney flashing done as part of a bigger job?
Almost always during a replacement, because the courses are off anyway and the metal can be built as a set from scratch. Doing it then is far better value than doing it later, and a scope that leaves the old flashing in place around a new roof is a scope worth questioning.
A new covering laid around old chimney metal gives you a roof whose weakest point is as old as the one you just removed. It is the clearest example of why flashing should be priced as part of the work rather than as an extra, and it is worth asking about explicitly before the job starts.
The same logic applies to a slate roof being repaired around a stack. The stone has to come up to get at the metal, so if the metal is near the end of its life, that is the moment. The hand techniques for taking slate up and resetting it are on the slate roof repair page.