Why does this happen to one house and not its neighbor?
Because it is driven by heat loss and air leakage, which vary house by house. Two identical houses with different insulation, different attic access hatches and different bathroom fan arrangements will behave quite differently under the same snow in the same cold spell.
Air leakage matters more than people expect. A gap around a chimney, an uninsulated attic hatch, recessed light fittings, or a bathroom fan discharging into the attic instead of outside all deliver warm moist air straight to the underside of the deck. The snow above melts in a patch, and the patch is enough to start the cycle.
Roof shape plays its part. A long shallow slope gives meltwater plenty of cold overhang to cross, a complex roof has valleys to freeze, and an unheated porch or a garage roof tied into a heated one creates a cold strip in the middle of a warm plane.
What should you not do when you see ice at the eave?
Do not get on the roof, do not chip at the ice, and do not throw salt into the gutter and hope. Chopping breaks the covering you are trying to protect, and an aggressive de-icer in a gutter corrodes metal and runs onto plantings below.
The impulse to knock the ice off is understandable and it is the most expensive instinct in winter roofing. Ice is bonded to the covering; a blow that breaks the ice breaks whatever it is stuck to. Slate cracks, asphalt tabs shatter when cold, and the openings left behind leak long after the snow has gone.
Pulling snow down from a roof with a long-handled rake, from the ground, is a reasonable step on a single-story eave if you can keep clear of what comes off. Above that height it stops being sensible. Nothing on a roof is worth a fall onto a frozen drive.
- Leave ladders on the ground; frozen ground and icy rungs are a bad combination
- Keep out from under the eave, since released ice comes down in slabs
- Do not run a hose up onto the roof to melt a channel, as the water refreezes and the hose stays
- Do not leave a bulging ceiling to drain itself; call and ask what to do with it
What happens inside the house while this is going on?
Water that has come over the top of the lowest courses runs into the eave, along the top plate of the wall, and into whatever it meets: insulation, plaster, window heads, sometimes the wall cavity. The visible stain is the last stage of that journey, not the first.
This is why a roofer wants to look inside as well as out. A wet patch at the ceiling line means the wall head has been wet for a while, and that affects paint, plaster, trim and any insulation in the cavity. The sooner it is dried out, the less of it has to be opened up.
Repeat events leave a record. If the same corner of the same room stains every February, the house is telling you where its weak point is, and that is a ventilation and air-sealing problem rather than a roof covering problem.
Does an ice barrier membrane prevent it?
It does not stop ice forming, but it changes the outcome when water backs up. A membrane bonded to the deck along the eaves and in the valleys gives the standing water a sealed surface to sit on instead of a line of nail holes and shingle laps.
This is one of the strongest arguments for stripping a roof rather than covering over it. The membrane can only go on a bare deck, so the moment it is installable is the moment the old covering comes off. An older roof here may well have nothing of the kind at the eave, which is why the water gets in so readily.
It is not a substitute for dealing with the heat. A membrane protects the deck while ice sits above it; it does nothing about the weight on the gutter, the icicles over the front path, or the ice working its way under the flashing further up. Both halves of the job are worth doing, and the roof replacement page covers where the membrane fits into the rebuild.