Why do skylights leak at the top rather than the bottom?
Because the uphill side is where water and snow collect. Everything running down the slope arrives at the head of the unit and has to be split around it, so if the head flashing is short, badly lapped or buried under drifted snow, that is where water gets in first.
This is also why curb height matters. On a shallow roof, or on a roof that holds snow for weeks, a unit sitting low in the plane is standing in water each time it thaws. Lifting the glazing on a curb takes the seal above the waterline.
Winter makes the geometry worse. Snow drifts on the uphill side of anything standing out of a slope and the meltwater behind it has to find a way past, which is the same mechanism that makes a wide chimney need a cricket. The eave version of that problem is on the ice dam removal and repair page.
How do you tell condensation from a leak?
Timing and pattern. Condensation appears in cold weather regardless of rain, is worst in bathrooms and kitchens, and shows as droplets across the inner face of the glazing. A leak follows rain or snowmelt, and typically runs from one point at the head or a corner.
A failed sealed unit is a special case: the glazing fogs between the panes and the unit no longer insulates well, so it runs cold and collects moisture. That is a reason to replace the unit itself rather than to rework the flashing, and it is easy to confirm visually.
The humidity in the room matters too. Where a skylight sits over a shower and the extract fan is weak or discharges into the attic, moisture is being delivered to the coldest surface in the room. Fixing the ventilation can stop the dripping without touching the roof, as the attic ventilation for ice dams page describes.
- Water only after rain or snowmelt, from a point source: suspect flashing
- Water in cold weather with no rain, spread across the glass: suspect condensation
- Milky or fogged glazing between panes: the sealed unit has failed
- Staining at the bottom corners of the shaft with a dry head: often condensation running down
When should a skylight be replaced with the roof?
Whenever both are near the end of their lives, because the flashing is part of the covering and cannot be renewed properly without disturbing it. Putting a new roof around an old skylight leaves the weakest point untouched and makes the eventual replacement a second disruption.
Cost aside, the quality argument is simple: during a replacement the deck is exposed, the courses are off and the detail can be built in the correct order from the deck up. Doing it later means working back into a finished roof, which is possible but never as clean.
This is one of the questions worth raising when a replacement is being scoped, along with chimney flashing and the low-slope areas. The roof replacement page sets out what else belongs in that conversation.
Does a skylight need review or a permit?
It can. Changing the size of an opening involves framing, which is a structural alteration, and the local building department is the place to ask what that requires. If the house is in a local historic district, a new or altered opening changes the appearance of a roof plane.
New Haven's Historic District Commission reviews roofing material in local districts, so any change visible from the street is a conversation to have before ordering, not afterward. A unit on a rear plane is a different matter from one cut into a street elevation, and the commission is the body that decides.
On the permit side, the honest answer is to ask. Aggregator sites disagree about what is required and what it costs in this area, so nothing of that kind is quoted here. The Department of Consumer Protection has advised confirming with the local building official that a permit was pulled where one is needed.