Why is standing water such a problem?
Because it turns every imperfection into a test. A seam that would shed a passing shower is under constant pressure from a pond, and water that cannot run off freezes in place in winter, expanding into any opening it has found. Weight is the other issue: ponded water is heavy.
Ponding also tells you something about the structure. A dish in the middle of a roof usually means the deck has deflected, and once water collects there it gets heavier and the deflection grows. That is a cycle worth interrupting early, by restoring fall with tapered material or by addressing the framing.
In winter the pond becomes a slab of ice sitting on the seams, and a blocked outlet guarantees it. This is the low-slope version of the eave problem that pitched roofs get, and it is why clearing outlets in the fall matters as much here as clearing gutters does there.
- Water remaining more than a couple of days after rain marks a fall or drainage problem
- A dish that deepens over the years points at the deck rather than the surface
- Blocked outlets and scuppers turn a minor fall problem into a pond
- Ice on a low-slope roof concentrates exactly where the water could not escape
Why do shingles not work on a shallow roof?
Because overlapping courses rely on gravity moving water off quickly. Below a certain pitch water moves slowly enough to be driven sideways under the laps, particularly by wind, and it will also back up behind anything that slows it. The roof then leaks through its design rather than through a fault.
This matters on houses here because a pitched main roof and a shallow rear roof often meet on the same building, and the temptation at replacement time is to carry one material across both. A roof scoped that way leaks on the shallow part within a few seasons.
The right answer is two systems and a proper transition between them, with the membrane carried up the slope and under the courses above so water coming off the pitched roof lands on waterproof material. The roof replacement page covers how that gets scoped on a mixed roof.
What about the parapet and the coping?
On a flat-roofed building the parapet is part of the roof. Water running down the wall arrives at the junction, and if the coping joints on top are open, water gets into the masonry and comes out inside, with the roof surface itself completely sound.
This is a frequent misdiagnosis on older multi-family buildings. The ceiling stains along an outside wall, the roof is inspected and found to be in reasonable order, and the real source is the top of the parapet several feet above. Dealing with the coping and the upstand together is the only way to settle it.
The upstand itself has rules of its own: it needs to turn up high enough above the finished surface to stay above standing water and snow, and it needs to be terminated mechanically so it cannot peel away as the wall and the roof move at different rates.
How does traffic damage these roofs?
Footfall is a real factor on a low-slope roof, because the surface is the waterproofing and there are no courses to spread the load. Service visits, antenna work, chimney sweeping and tenants using a porch roof as a terrace all put wear exactly where it does most harm.
Punctures from dropped tools, scuffs from grit ground underfoot, and compressed insulation from repeated walking on the same route all shorten the life of the assembly. Where access is needed regularly, a walkway can be built in so the traffic has somewhere to go.
On a porch stack roof the traffic question is social rather than technical. If the household below treats it as a deck, the roof needs to be built for that; if it is not built for it, then the arrangement needs rethinking before the roof is repaired again.