Why does intake matter more than exhaust?
Because an exhaust vent will pull air from wherever it can get it. If the soffits are blocked, the easiest source is the heated house below, through every gap in the ceiling. The attic then gets warmer and wetter than it was before the vent was installed.
A balanced system has at least as much free area low down as it does high up, so the air that leaves at the ridge is replaced by cold outside air at the eave. The flow washes the underside of the deck and carries away both heat and moisture. Get that right and the deck stays cold in winter and cooler in summer.
Blocked intake is extremely common in houses where insulation has been upgraded without baffles. Somebody blows the attic floor to a good depth, the material drifts into the eaves, and the soffit vents are sealed from the inside while still looking open from the street.
- Free intake area at the soffit, clear along the whole eave
- Baffles holding insulation back from the air path at every bay
- Exhaust high on the roof, sized to match rather than exceed the intake
- One exhaust strategy per attic space rather than two competing ones
What does moisture have to do with it?
Warm indoor air carries water vapor, and when it reaches a cold roof deck that vapor condenses. Over a winter that shows as frost on the nails and the boards, then as staining and in bad cases as decay in the sheathing, independent of any leak through the covering.
Showers, cooking and laundry are the main sources, which is why the destination of a bathroom fan duct matters so much. A fan that discharges into the attic is pumping warm wet air at the coldest surface in the building. Ducting it out through a wall or roof outlet, with a proper termination, removes that at a stroke.
Condensation also explains why a homeowner sometimes reports a leak with no storm and no ice. Water dripping off frost-covered nail heads on the first mild day looks exactly like a roof leak from below, and the roof covering may be in perfect condition.
When is this work worth doing on its own?
Whenever ice forms in the same place every winter, whenever the attic shows frost or staining on the deck, and whenever the roof melts in patches while the eave stays frozen. It is also the natural companion to a replacement, since the deck is open and the ridge accessible.
Doing it with a replacement is efficient and it is not required. Sealing and baffling can be carried out from inside the attic on a roof that has years left, and in a hard winter that is often the most useful work a crew can do on a house without touching the covering.
The order to think about is cause first, consequence second. Clearing ice is described on the ice dam removal and repair page and belongs to the emergency; this page belongs to the quiet months when the real fix is possible.
Does better venting help in summer too?
Yes, though the winter case is the one that produces leaks. A vented attic runs cooler, which takes some load off the covering and off upstairs rooms. Shingles bake from below in an unvented attic, which does not help the life of the roof.
The same air path that carries winter moisture out carries summer heat out. That is why ventilation is specified as a year-round system rather than a seasonal measure, and why the arrangement is not changed to suit one season at the expense of the other.
Summer here brings thunderstorm and tropical season as well as heat, so an attic that stays dry and breathable is also an attic where the first sign of a storm leak is visible rather than hidden under damp insulation.