What decides the scale of the job?
Area and pitch set the labor, the number of existing layers sets the tear-off, and the complexity of the roof sets everything else. A simple gable with two planes is a different animal from a roof with four dormers, two valleys, a chimney and a porch tie-in, even if the square footage is the same.
Pitch changes how the work is done. A steep slope needs staging, roof jacks and slower movement, which lengthens the job. A very low pitch limits which coverings can be used at all, because shingles rely on gravity and lap to shed water and stop working below a certain angle.
Junctions are the other multiplier. Every dormer cheek, skylight curb, chimney and sidewall is a detail that has to be flashed, and details take time. This is why two houses on the same street with the same footprint can carry quite different scopes.
- Roof area and the number of separate planes
- Pitch, and whether staging is needed to work safely
- How many coverings are already on the deck
- Condition of the sheathing, fascia and rafter tails once exposed
- The count of chimneys, dormers, skylights and sidewall junctions
- Whether gutters, vents or a low-slope section are part of the same job
Is there any case for roofing over the old covering?
It is sometimes done on a sound single layer, and it is usually the wrong economy on a house of this age. Covering over hides the deck, adds weight, and gives the new fasteners a soft and uneven base, so the roof above it is built on something nobody has inspected.
The savings come from skipping the tear-off, which is real labor and real disposal. What you give up is the one chance in twenty or thirty years to see the sheathing, renew the flashing properly and put an ice barrier at the eave. On a roof that has ice dams in a hard winter, skipping the barrier is the expensive choice.
There is also the next replacement to consider. A second layer makes the eventual strip heavier and messier, and a third is heavier again. A roofer who recommends stripping is not inflating the job; they are putting the new covering on wood they have actually looked at.
What about permits and registration?
Ask the local building department what the work needs, because requirements and process differ by town and no useful figure can be quoted here. Separately, the Connecticut Department of Consumer Protection registers home improvement contractors and has said that roofing companies must be registered with it, with a lookup at elicense.ct.gov.
New Haven's building department takes applications, and the city's general building permit form includes a roofing checkbox, so the route exists. What the department asks for on a given job is for the department to say. The Department of Consumer Protection has also advised homeowners to confirm with the local building official that a permit was pulled where one is required.
The same agency's advice on paperwork is worth following: the contract should be signed before work starts, and you should know what is in it. The guide on checking a roofer's registration in Connecticut sets out how the lookup is used, and roof permits in New Haven County covers the permit question in more depth.
What should be written down before the material is ordered?
The slopes included, the number of layers coming off, the treatment of sheathing found to be soft, the ventilation plan, which flashings are being renewed, what happens to the gutters, and how debris and nails are handled. A scope that is silent on sheathing is the one that produces surprises.
Sheathing is the clause that matters most on an old house, because nobody can price what they cannot see. A clear scope says how replacement boards are measured and handled when they are found, so the conversation on the day is about quantity and not about principle.
Ventilation deserves a line too. A roof that is replaced without addressing a blocked soffit or an unvented attic will perform no better in winter than the one it replaced, which is why the attic ventilation for ice dams page exists as a separate job.