Call to reach a local rooferNew Haven, CT
Call (833) 751-2102
Call to reach a local rooferCall any time(833) 751-2102
Guide

Repairing, matching or changing an old roof covering

Older houses here commonly carry slate and postwar ones asphalt shingle. How each is repaired, what fails first, and when a local district review applies.

Illustration for the guide "Repairing, matching or changing an old roof covering" (New Haven, CT)
Short answer

Older houses in this area commonly carry slate and postwar ones asphalt shingle. The decision about a pre-war roof is rarely slate against shingle in the abstract: it is whether the stone on your own roof is sound, whether the fasteners holding it have given up, and whether the house sits where the material is reviewed.

Key takeaways

  • No reliable figure exists for how this city divides between slate and asphalt shingle, so treat any share you are quoted as marketing.
  • Slate often outlives the nails that hold it, and a roof with sound stone and failing fasteners is repaired rather than replaced.
  • Slate work is hand work done piece by piece, with its own tools, and it is a different trade from laying shingle.
  • Valley and chimney metal usually fails before the covering does, and on an old roof that is the most common source of a leak.
  • Changing from slate to another covering alters the load on the framing and the look of the house, and both need checking first.
  • In a local historic district the Historic District Commission reviews roofing material, and its minutes record it considering like-kind replacement and simulated slate.

What is actually on the roof?

That has to be established before anything else, because the same house can carry different coverings on different sections. A main roof in slate with an asphalt rear addition and a low-slope porch roof is an ordinary combination here.

The age of the house is a guide, not an answer. New Haven's own Vision 2025 housing chapter notes that well over a third of the city's homes predate the Second World War, and a house of that vintage may well have been built with slate. It may also have been re-covered twice since, which is exactly what a first inspection establishes.

Read the roof section by section. A technician looks at the main slopes, the rear ell, any dormer cheeks, the porch and the bay roofs, because each may have been done at a different time by a different hand. The transitions between them are where the detailing gets interesting and where the water tends to find a way in.

Ask for that section-by-section description in writing. A scope that treats the whole house as one covering will come unstuck on the day a crew reaches the join between two of them.

Why does a slate roof usually fail at the nails?

Because the stone is more durable than the steel holding it. On a long-lived slate roof the fasteners corrode and lose their grip before the slates themselves wear out, and pieces begin sliding free one at a time.

The symptom is recognizable: individual slates missing or slipped, scattered rather than clustered, with the surrounding stone still in good order. Pieces turn up in the gutter or on the ground, usually whole rather than shattered. A roof shedding slates that way has a fastener problem rather than a covering problem.

It matters because the two conditions lead to opposite recommendations. Sound stone on failing nails is repaired slate by slate, and the roof carries on for years. Stone that is delaminating, flaking at the edges or breaking under its own weight is a covering at the end of its service, and patching it is throwing good work at bad.

Telling the two apart is a job for someone who handles slate regularly, from close up rather than from the driveway. Slate roof repair describes what that assessment involves and what it concludes.

How is a slate repair actually done?

One piece at a time, by hand. The broken slate is cut free, the replacement is slid into position, and it is secured in a way that does not require lifting the course above it. Nothing about the process resembles laying shingle.

The slate above the damaged piece overlaps it, so the old fastener has to be cut from underneath with a thin ripping tool rather than pulled out from above. The replacement is then held by a hook or a strip fixed into the joint below, because there is no way to nail into the covered area without breaking the slate that covers it.

Matching is its own skill. A replacement wants to be close in thickness, size and color to what is around it, and an old roof has weathered to a tone that a new piece will not share immediately. Salvaged stone of a similar age often sits better than new stone, and a roofer who works in slate will usually have some.

Walking on slate is the other constraint. The stone cracks under a boot in the wrong place, so access is from staging, ladders laid on padding, or hook ladders rather than by strolling up the slope. That is part of why a slate repair takes longer than its size suggests.

Where do old roofs leak, if not through the covering?

At the metal. Valleys, chimney flashings, dormer sidewalls and the junctions around any penetration are where water is turned away by sheet metal rather than by slope, and metal on a pre-war house has often been replaced less often than the covering.

A valley takes the drainage of two slopes into one channel and carries the heaviest flow on the roof. When the metal in it thins or opens at a seam, water goes under the covering on both sides, which produces a stain some distance from the valley itself. That is the single most common leak found on these houses.

Brick chimneys are the second. The joint needs a base piece, step pieces up each side and a counter-flashing set into the mortar, and all of it moves as the masonry weathers. Sealant smeared over a failing joint is a repair with a season's life in it. Chimney flashing repair sets out what a proper rebuild of the joint involves.

So a leak on an old roof is not evidence that the covering is finished. Trace the source before anyone quotes a replacement, which is the point of leak diagnosis and flashing repair.

What changes if you move from slate to shingle?

The weight on the framing, the detailing at every edge and the appearance of the house. Removing a heavy covering and laying a lighter one is not simply a substitution, and the framing, the fastening and the trim all need looking at.

Slate is heavy, and the roof structure under an old slate covering was built to carry it. Taking that load off is not a structural problem in itself, but the condition of the sheathing beneath is usually unknown until the stone is off, and plank decking that has been dry for a century can be soft in two places and perfect everywhere else.

Detailing changes too. Slate is laid with its own headlap, its own trim metal at hips and ridges, and its own approach to valleys. A different covering wants different metal at every one of those points, so the scope should name each junction rather than assume they carry over. What moves a roof replacement quote lists them.

Then there is the look. A slate roof reads as part of the house from the street, and a change is visible from a long way off. On some houses that is nobody's business but yours, and on others it is reviewed, which is the next question.

Is the material reviewed in a historic district?

In a local historic district, yes. The city's Historic District Commission reviews roofing material, and its minutes from recent years record it considering like-kind replacements and simulated slate. The conversation belongs before anything is ordered.

The practical consequence is a sequence, not an obstacle. Find out whether the address sits inside a local district, ask the commission what it expects for a roof like yours, and only then settle the covering and the scope. A material agreed in advance saves a scope being written twice and a crew being stood down.

No rule specific to slate was found in what the commission has published, so nothing of that sort is stated here. Ask the commission directly about your own address and your own proposal, and treat what it tells you as the answer rather than relying on what was approved for a neighbor.

Beyond the districts, plenty of old houses here are not reviewed at all, and the choice is yours. Historic district roof work covers how a job is prepared when the review does apply.

How do the two coverings compare on an old house?

Not as a league table but as a set of trade-offs that depend on what is up there now. The table sets out how each behaves on a pre-war roof and what each demands of the house and the crew.

Read the table as questions to ask rather than as a recommendation. The right answer for a Guilford house of real age, in a town whose own heritage page counts more than 675 dwellings predating 1911, is likely to differ from the right answer for a postwar cape in Trumbull, where more than half the housing dates from the 1940s through the 1960s.

What the two cases share is the order of work: establish what is on the roof, establish whether the covering or the metal is the problem, establish what the framing and the district allow, and only then choose. Skipping to the choice is how a homeowner ends up paying for a full replacement to cure a valley.

If the roof in question is a low-slope section rather than a pitched one, it belongs in a different discussion entirely, and low-slope roofs on New Haven triple-deckers takes it up.

How each covering behaves on an older house here
ConsiderationSlateAsphalt shingle
Typical failureFasteners corrode before the stone wearsSurface ages, tabs curl, seals break
Repair methodPiece by piece, by hand, with ripping toolsCourses replaced in sections
Walking on itCracks underfoot, so access is from stagingCan be walked when conditions allow
Weight on framingHeavy, and the structure was built for itLight, which changes the loading
Matching an old roofThickness, size and tone all have to matchColor match to a weathered roof is approximate
District reviewOften the existing material in an old districtMay need discussion before it is chosen
Who does the workA roofer who works in slate regularlyA general roofing crew

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell slate from a shingle that looks like it?

Slate is stone: it rings rather than thuds, the edges are thicker and slightly irregular, and broken pieces on the ground are brittle and layered. A product made to resemble it will flex. From the ground it can be genuinely hard to call, which is one reason the first visit includes a close look.

Is it worth repairing a very old slate roof?

Often, yes, if the stone is sound. Slate frequently outlives the fasteners holding it, and replacing slipped pieces keeps a roof in service for a long time. The judgment turns on whether the stone itself is still solid or has begun to flake and delaminate, which is assessed close up.

Can a few slates be replaced without redoing the roof?

Yes, and that is normal practice. Each piece is cut free from beneath and the replacement is secured without disturbing the course above. The work is slow relative to its size because of the access and the matching, not because it is complicated.

What share of houses here have slate?

No reliable figure exists, and none is published on this site. What can be said is that the older houses in this area commonly carry slate and the postwar ones asphalt shingle, as general practice. Anyone quoting you a percentage for the city is quoting something they cannot support.

Do I need permission to change my roof covering?

If the house is in a local historic district, the Historic District Commission reviews roofing material, so ask the commission before ordering anything. Separately, whether the job needs a building permit is for your local building department to confirm, and that question is covered in the permits guide.

Will a new covering look odd next to the neighbors?

On a street of similar houses with their original roofs, a change in material is visible from a distance. Whether that matters is yours to weigh outside a district, and the commission's to weigh inside one. Ask to see samples in daylight on your own roof before you decide.

Sources

  1. City of New Haven
  2. Wikipedia: New Haven, Connecticut

This guide is general information for New Haven County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.

Skip the guesswork. Call for a straight answer.

Tell us what's happening and we'll tell you honestly whether it's a quick fix, and what help should cost.

Keep reading

More guides

A storm roof claim, from the first photograph onward

A storm claim on a roof turns on evidence and sequence: dated photographs taken before anything is touched, a written description of what the wind or ice did, and a clear separation between damage from the event and wear that was already there.

Check the register before you sign anything

Home improvement contractors in this state are registered with the Connecticut Department of Consumer Protection, and the department's 2025 alert says roofing companies must be registered with it.

WhatsApp